Understanding SharePoint’s Limitations as a Knowledge Management Solution
Phil Green
The SharePoint juggernaut continues in corporate enterprise environments. But 15 years after the product was first launched, clear evidence of SharePoint’s strengths and weaknesses as a knowledge management platform is emerging from objective industry observers.
The RealStory Group (a vendor-neutral research and advisory firm) is one organization that has done quite a bit of analysis on SharePoint. Lucidea’s experience working on thousands of KM implementations mirrors RealStory Group’s findings. Let’s examine SharePoint’s strengths and weaknesses, and what these mean for you.
SharePoint’s Strengths
- “Basic file sharing collaboration at the workgroup level remains SharePoint’s biggest strength” according to the RealStory Group’s research.
- SharePoint is also a well acknowledged development platform for building all sorts of applications (including KM applications).
SharePoint’s Weaknesses
- As a development environment SharePoint is very complex. “Once you get beyond the basics, {the} platform quickly becomes deceptively complicated and developer-intensive” notes the RealStory Group, adding “Microsoft markets the platform as a ready-made, easy-to-use product for replacing your dependence on shared drives, but enterprise customers quickly realize that business stakeholders often require much more.”
- Enforcing uniform enterprise standards for items such as the information architecture is also highly problematic. According to the RealStory Group the “emphasis on localized, bottom-up site provisioning encourages departmental freelancing that mitigates against enterprise governance.”
What does this mean for you?
- Contrary to popular belief, SharePoint is NOT an out-of-the-box knowledge management solution, for anything but very basic needs. So, if you choose SharePoint for your knowledge management needs, you should plan for a long and costly development cycle.
- Because of SharePoint’s end-user (or bottom-up) orientation, establishing enterprise standards is difficult; and therefore, avoiding information chaos is far from assured.
Lucidea’s experience with customers mirrors these two points. We often see SharePoint development cycles that stretch from months into years. We also see migrations of documents from networked drives to SharePoint, but with no discernible increase in findability or basic organization.
Our advice—when deciding on a new knowledge management solution—is to work with a competent and experienced KM vendor who can provide you with a tailored solution that meets your needs within weeks or a few months, and if necessary, ensure that this solution can be integrated into your SharePoint environment. Without this assurance, be prepared for a long and costly SharePoint development cycle.
Do you have experience with SharePoint and KM? Please share it.
Our good friends at CMSWire have made an excerpt of this research available as a free download here.
Similar Posts
Lucidea’s Lens: Knowledge Management Thought Leaders Part 64 – Mark Britz
KM leader Mark Britz is a performance strategist, helping people be better connected, build on strengths, identify opportunities to improve workflow.
Lucidea’s Lens: Knowledge Management Thought Leaders Part 63 – Nick Bontis
KM thought leader Nick Bontis is with the Institute for Intellectual Capital Research, which specializes in human capital diagnostic assessments
Lucidea’s Lens: Knowledge Management Thought Leaders Part 62 – Max Boisot
KM thought leader Max Boisot was known for his ideas about the information economy, the Information Space, social capital, and social learning theory.
Lucidea’s Lens: Knowledge Management Thought Leaders Part 61 – David Bennet
KM thought leader David Bennet focuses on achieving growth and understanding through questions about knowledge, consciousness, and meaning.
Hosting service
Enjoy all of the benefits of your Lucidea solution with secure, reliable, stress free hosting
Programs & incentives
No matter your size or budget, we’ve got you covered, today and tomorrow