The Complicated Feelings Librarians May Have About AI

Lauren Hays
I recently read a SubStack post from Daniel Stanford titled AI Festivus: An AI Workshop for the Rest of Us.
In it, he highlighted some of the common themes seen in presentations and discussions on generative AI. Then, he indicated a need to give people space to process their feelings about AI, observing that this has been missing from many of the presentations he has seen or been involved with.
His list of themes resonated with my own experience and my own work. I have tried to offer solutions, see the positives, and acknowledge the concerns (i.e., ethical dilemmas). However, I have rarely sat with my own feelings or provided space for others to do so.
While it may be impossible to provide space for others to process feelings in a blog post, I want to take this post to acknowledge that change is hard—and GenAI will be disruptive.
AI’s Impact on Library Work: Cataloging and Research
GenAI will affect how we do our work and the type(s) of work we engage in.
For example, GenAI will likely have a direct impact on cataloging and technical services in libraries. While a person will still need to check records and make decisions about classifications, much of what’s involved in cataloging and technical services can be completed with GenAI. Over a year ago, the free version of ChatGPT was able to create a solid MARC record.
Gen AI is also already influencing how people conduct research and is likely to have an even bigger impact in the future. Researchers will need to learn more about the evaluation of sources and how to uncover material that is not represented in many large language models.
These two examples suggest a shift from traditional research and cataloging methods to a more dynamic, technology-augmented approach that values both technological efficiency and human intellectual insight.
This shift may be uncomfortable for many. We are all creatures of habit and adjusting to major shifts in workflow and the skills valued in the workforce can be disconcerting.
Understanding Our Emotional Response to GenAI
In navigating the transformative potential of GenAI, we should engage in reflective practice that centers on our core professional values. The introduction of GenAI can trigger complex emotional responses—uncertainty, anxiety, or even a sense of professional displacement. These feelings are natural and valid.
For library and information science professionals, these uncomfortable feelings likely stem from core values such as:
- Intellectual freedom
- Preservation of authentic knowledge
- Ethical information access
- Protection of human expertise
- Commitment to critical thinking
- Maintaining the integrity of research and information systems
Acknowledging these emotions is not a sign of resistance, but an important step in thoughtful technological integration. By sitting with the discomfort and examining its roots, we can:
- Identify which specific aspects of AI feel most challenging
- Recognize the unique contributions of human judgment
- Develop strategies for meaningful technological adaptation
- Proactively shape how AI is implemented in our professional context (including supporting AI policy development)
Technological Advancement is Not Something to Be Feared
The goal is not to resist the change GenAI brings, but to ensure that technological advances align with and enhance the core mission and values of the profession. This approach transforms potential anxiety into a constructive dialogue about maintaining professional integrity while embracing innovative tools.

Lauren Hays
Dr. Lauren Hays is an Assistant Professor of Instructional Technology at the University of Central Missouri, and a frequent presenter and interviewer on topics related to libraries and librarianship. Please read Lauren’s other posts relevant to special librarians. Learn about Lucidea’s powerful integrated library systems, SydneyDigital, and GeniePlus, used daily by innovative special librarians in libraries of all types, sizes and budgets.
**Disclaimer: Any in-line promotional text does not imply Lucidea product endorsement by the author of this post.
Never miss another post. Subscribe today!
Similar Posts
Interview with the Editor: Bobbi L. Newman on Well-Being in the Library Workplace
Enjoy Lauren Hays’ interview with Bobbi L. Newman on why workplace well-being matters, how managers can drive meaningful change, and what steps libraries can take to create a culture of trust and support.
Interview with the Author: Brighid Gonzales on Library Website Design
In her new book, Library Website Design and Development, Brighid M. Gonzales provides a step-by-step guide to help librarians create websites that engage and support their users. In this interview, Brighid shares insights on trends, opportunities, and best practices for building a strong library website.
The Importance of Professional Networking: Tips for Special Librarians
For many special librarians, the idea of professional networking can feel daunting, especially for those who thrive in quiet, research-driven environments. Lauren Hays shares her journey from reluctant networker to engaged community member, offering practical tips to help you build authentic professional relationships that benefit both you and your field.
Interview with the Author: Jim Cortada on Today’s Facts and the Evolution of Information
Dr. James Cortada, historian and senior research fellow at the Charles Babbage Institute, explores the history of information in his forthcoming book. By examining how information has been created, organized, and used over time, Cortada reveals patterns that continue to shape modern librarianship and knowledge management.
Leave a Comment
Comments are reviewed and must adhere to our comments policy.
0 Comments